I refuse to issue a fatwa against Bill Palmer. 1. In response to a denunciation from one identifying himself as the "Twelfth Hausmann," I submitted Bill Palmer's Usenet postings to a committee of mullahs for analysis. I was surprised to hear they did not find a single phrase offensive to Islam; even many basically sound people can be found to have written at least one error, if you examine their writings closely enough. It turns out, however, that none of the committee members could read more than 5 lines into any Bill Palmer post without falling into a deep, practically comatose sleep. Thus, this clearance should not be regarded as definitive. 2. As a secondary charge, the "Twelfth Hausmann" suggested that Bill Palmer postings, by their very wordiness, inanity, and mindless profusion, were an "offense against God." We felt some sympathy for this argument. Nevertheless, there was reasonable doubt whether BP postings actually cause measurable harm. It was even argued they might serve as a penance of God for those who find too much time to waste on a suspect medium. Weighing all these factors, we could not justify an award of higher than two cents for anyone executing a fatwa against Bill Palmer. Given this, we decided not to issue a fatwa, lest they be cheapened. --Ayatollah Khomeini